Is the Atlantic Striped Bass Headed for Another Crisis?

By Bailey Kennedy –

striped bass overfishing

Whether you call them stripers, linesiders, rockfish or one of the many other monikers hung on the Atlantic striped bass, fishermen along the eastern seaboard agree the fish’s combination of size and fight make it a fun challenge to catch. (Check out what Dave Miller has to say about them here.) However, striper populations have taken a turn for the worse and blame is being laid at the door of pollution, overfishing, and mismanagement with other habitat-based threats taking their fair share as well.

Everyone involved agrees that there have been troubling fluctuations in rockfish populations. However, as with any problem involving multiple state agencies, field-specific experts, commercial industry, and the rest of us average joes, a lot has been said, but no consensus on how to address the issue at hand has been reached. So, here’s the skinny on what’s happening to stripers and how conservation-minded anglers might be the best solution.

WHAT’S HAPPENING NOW?

Whether you’re an avid striper fisherman and have been following this story worriedly or this is the first time you’re hearing about it, here’s the bottom line: there are fewer Atlantic striped bass than there were – but it’s not that simple. The waters of the issue are muddied because the main problem isn’t the downturn in straight numbers, it’s the decrease in female SSB. (That’s spawning stock biomass for anyone wondering. It’s the total weight of all the fish in a population old enough to spawn.)

According to the report published by the Atlantic States Marine Fisheries Commission (ASMFC) in 2016 “Exploitable biomass (January 1) increased from 1,399 metric tons in 1982 to its peak at 27 thousand metric tons in 2006 (Figure 12C). Exploitable biomass has since declined to 13,171 metric tons in 2015.”

It’s worth noting that this same report is prefaced with a statement by the Atlantic Striped Bass Technical Committee stating, “In 2015, the Atlantic striped bass stock was not overfished or experiencing overfishing based on the point estimates of fully-recruited fishing mortality (F) and female spawning stock biomass (SSB) relative to the reference points defined in Atlantic Striped Bass Fishery Management Plan.”

THIS IS STARTING TO SOUND FAMILIAR…

If that mention of the low numbers from 1982 is ringing any bells, it’s because this isn’t the first time striped bass have taken a nosedive. In the late ’70s and early ’80s, overfishing and environmental factors caused a plummet in the striper population resulting in drastic action on the part of management agencies in the form of a five-year kibosh on striped bass fishing along the eastern seaboard from 1985 to 1990.

Having that in our rearview is actually an encouraging factor now for two reasons: 1.) Things now haven’t gotten nearly as bad as they have been in the past. 2.) Stripers made a huge comeback before, and if we handle it right this time, they can do it again.

WHAT DOES THE DATA SAY?

At this point you might be saying, “Ok, I get that there are issues, but what’s being done about them?” As things currently stand (as of the August 2018 meeting of the Atlantic Striped Bass Management Board) the ASMFC has in place Addendum IV which imposed a 20+% limit on the harvest in October 2014 that continues through the present.

This did improve the total fishing mortality numbers significantly, putting them below the acceptable threshold and ideal target percentages. However, female SSB is still in decline. If the trend continues, and female breeding stock numbers continue to fall, the overall population is going to reflect that on a significant scale. In a nutshell, there are fewer breeding females and it isn’t strictly because of overfishing, meaning this isn’t going to be a quick and easy fix.

HOW ABOUT THE UNOFFICIAL STORY?

I think we all know that wherever official stories, management agencies, and committees exist, there is always the less clean-cut (and potentially more accurate) version of the facts. One fact of note in this debacle is that striped bass are managed exclusively by the ASMFC, not in conjunction with other federal agencies and are therefore not necessarily subject to federal regulations on the subject.

Contrast this to the summer flounder for example, which is jointly managed by the ASMFC and the Mid-Atlantic Fishery Management Council, a federal entity. The Magnuson-Stevens Act mandates compliance of federal agencies to maintain population stock. This means that in 2017, the summer flounder was found to be in decline and its management agencies were required to alter the regs to promote recovery. The striped bass has no such built-in regulation, and it could be argued that the only reason Addendum IV was successfully implemented was due to public outcry and advocacy from recreational anglers.

I should add that it would be negligent of me to paint the ASFMC as the villain in a situation that doesn’t necessarily have one, as the organization’s goal is stated as sustainable management, and back in the ’80s it played a big role in striper recovery. They just might need some encouragement in the right direction. A large portion of those concerned about stripers make their livelihood off the continued ability to harvest them, and immediate economic concerns are no joke. However, if ecological quandaries are solved using economic data, it could put species sustainability at risk.

HOW CAN I HELP?

  1. Get educated: If you live in an Atlantic coastal state, check out what your state has on the books regarding stripers. Here are some links with info to help you do that. (ME, NH, MA, DE, CT, NJ, NY, MD, VA, NC, SC, GA, FL) Knowing what is going on in your locale can be the first step in enacting positive change.
  2. Voice your opinion: Now that you’ve learned more about the situation, aren’t taking my word for it, and know what you’re talking about, what’s next on the list? You need to tell the right people what you think. The next meeting of the ASMFC is coming up in February regarding Atlantic striped bass, and you can access their public input page here to send in comments and concerns.

To sum it all up, rockfish may be down but are far from out. The goal of sustainable populations isn’t far out of reach. As conservationists as well as anglers, we may need to be willing to curb our striper harvest both recreationally and commercially on a temporary basis. However, with good management and advocacy, the striped bass will be preserved for both the near future and the next generation of fishermen.

We welcome your comments on this very important topic.

4 thoughts on “Is the Atlantic Striped Bass Headed for Another Crisis?

  1. Robin Barrett

    Stripers have always been such a reward to catch… I can see why they are getting overfished. Hopefully, we’ll do something to help these fish restore themselves back to their former glory.

    Reply
    1. Dorado

      That’s so true, Robin. We’ve been there before and I think we have enough experience and data now to take the proper corrective actions to bring their stocks back. But it takes effort, and it’s not just the responsibility of the fish and game agencies; we anglers must also do our part.

      Reply
  2. JT Errol

    Thanks for the information. I live in the northeast and striped bass are a favorite of mine. I’ve heard talk of a population decrease but, until now, hadn’t gotten the full story. Hopefully, this can be combated with sensible management strategies.

    Reply
    1. Dorado

      JT, I remember the the Striper’s struggles of the 1980s and hope it never comes to that again. I’m hopeful that the lessons we learned then will help us to maintain strong stocks and avert another crisis.

      Reply

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *